Log in

No account? Create an account

in a web of glass, pinned to the edges of vision

So crossposting one's entries to Facebook is what everyone's freaking…

I'd forgotten how often we saw Magritte

mucha mosaic

Previous Entry Share Next Entry
So crossposting one's entries to Facebook is what everyone's freaking out about, right now. I just tested this: I attempted to crosspost a comment on my own locked LJ entry over to Facebook.

Now, the checkbox for crossposting was NOT grayed out- I was able to tell LJ to send it to Facebook. I told it to crosspost a comment on a friends-locked LJ entry- and it did not appear on my Facebook.

Either there's a great deal of shrieking going on about something untrue (not that that ever happens on LJ), or LJ is working EVEN WORSE THAN USUAL at accomplishing something they intended to. In future, I would suggest that people test things before they jump to a worst-case-scenario conclusion about what has happened.

Yes, Chicken Little, the LJ isn't falling.
  • Oh that's curious... I can't edit it to make a post appear on Facebook, once I've hit 'post comment'.

    Test-a test-a test...
  • Hi. Testing!
    BTW, I don't have you on my FB yet. Let's be friends there! Although, my posting style is different there and pretty superficial.
  • They may have 'fixed' some issues -- rm did the same test you did and comments in a friends-locked entry did appear on Twitter.
    • Oh ho! Well, good of them to be proactive about fixing a screwup, then!
      • I was aware of at least three people who tested and had f-locked stuff show up. rm counts as the fourth person.

        I'm with you on the testing..and that is the thing that bothered me most, other than the obvious feeling of "I don't like the idea of someone publicly linking to their stuff in my locked journal" issues. If this is going to be par for the course when it comes to implementing new features, it is only a matter of time before they do something that say...unlocks every post in your journal on accident, or something equally as ridiculous, for five minutes.

        Test, test, and test again in a beta sandbox.
  • Details findable here -- http://meowvatar.livejournal.com/2056359.html
    • But, on the other hand... http://chiller.livejournal.com/2503493.html
      • That's an excellent example of how this can inadvertently go very very bad. When you combine that with the way FB can turn up some totally random connections*, this gets pretty scary.

        * Here's a real example of random connection: A person turned up in that little friend-suggestion thing that FB does over on the right sidebar. I do in fact know her; she's a friend of friends from college, someone I knew well enough to say, "Hey, hi," to if I passed her on campus. However, you know how FB does that little "Person X, person Y, and Z other people are mutual friends" thing? In this case, persons X & Y were not college friends, as I would have expected, but were my cousin and his wife -- she lives in the same town now, and their kids played T-ball together. I would never in a brazillion years have anticipated that connection. On FB it doesn't worry me -- I've got things locked down tightly enough that if I say something to a filtered group, it doesn't get echoed on other people's feeds when they comment and stuff, and I also treat FB as if it's a huge party, where you know who's in the little corner you're in and talking to, but you don't know who's on the other side of the room and you never know when some comment you make will fall into one of those sudden silences crowds sometimes get, and I just don't say anything there that I would be embarrassed to have overheard. But I *do* speak much more candidly here -- it's more like a little private party, in my living room -- and the idea of someone posting a comment to a post, not with a quote but as in chiller's example just something with enough internal context to it, to their FB where I have no idea what their privacy settings are or where their connections lead.... Yeah, that's scary.
Powered by LiveJournal.com