I'm sure it puts you in company with a buttload of women of around the same age. Adolescents aren't really noted for having fabulous taste. Heck, there must be far worse people to have crushed on.
(This suddenly makes me realize there was at least one benefit to being a bit of a late bloomer: the first celebrity crush I can recall having was on Emma Peel. Which is something I feel no worries about admitting; it's still considered a mark of good taste.)
And the first guy I recall having noticeable hots for was Sting as Feyd-Rautha Harkonnen in David Lynch's Dune.